How to Keep Your Top Performers
Your best people are the ones with the most options and, often, the least attention. They do not need to be managed less. They need to be invested in more.
Keep top performers by investing in them more, not leaving them alone: give them challenging work and a visible path to grow, recognize their contributions specifically, protect them from burnout and from carrying weaker performers, pay them fairly, and ask regularly what they want next. Top performers rarely leave over one thing; they leave when they feel stuck, unnoticed or overloaded.
There is a quiet mistake many leaders make with their best people. Because top performers do not need much help, they get very little attention. Leaders spend their time on the people who are struggling and assume the stars are fine. Then one day a star resigns, and the leader is genuinely surprised.
Top performers have the most options. They are the people recruiters call first, and in a market where Gallup finds more than half of U.S. workers are either actively looking or watching for a new job, those calls are constant. Keeping them takes deliberate effort.
Why do top performers leave?
In my experience, it is rarely about one thing. It is usually a slow combination: they stop growing, they stop being noticed, and they carry more than their share. Strong people often get rewarded for being strong with more work, including the work of people who are not pulling their weight. Over time, that feels less like trust and more like punishment.
Common reasons top performers walk away
- They stop growing. They have mastered the role and nobody has talked with them about what is next.
- They are overloaded. Good work is rewarded with more work.
- They carry others. They watch weaker performance go unaddressed while they pick up the slack.
- They feel unseen. Their results are expected rather than recognized.
- The pay gap gets too wide. Market offers outpace what they are paid.
Invest in them more, not less
Top performers want to keep getting better. Give them stretch work, harder problems, chances to lead projects and mentor others, and exposure to senior leaders. Ask them directly what they want to learn and where they want to go. The question alone tells them you see a future for them here. See How to Have a Career Conversation With an Employee.
I have promoted many people who were strong performers, but I promote the ones who also make the people around them better. Telling a top performer that developing others is the path to leadership gives them a reason to stay and a way to grow at the same time. I wrote about that in How to Decide Who to Promote Into Leadership.
Recognize the work, not just the result
When someone consistently delivers, it is easy to stop saying anything. Do not let excellence become invisible. Recognize specifically what they did and how they did it. Gallup and Workhuman found employees who get high-quality recognition are 65% less likely to be looking or watching for another job (Gallup, 2024). That matters most for the people everyone else is trying to hire.
Protect them from carrying everyone else
Nothing drives out a strong performer faster than watching poor performance go unaddressed while they pick up the slack. Address underperformance directly and fairly. It is not only the right thing for the team; it is a retention strategy for your best people. See How to Have a Difficult Conversation With an Employee.
Also watch their workload. Top performers rarely say no, which makes them some of the most likely people to burn out. Ask what they could stop doing, and help them do it.
Pay them fairly, and talk about it
Pay is not everything, but a top performer who learns they are underpaid by a wide margin will not stay for culture alone. Review their pay against the market regularly and before they have to ask. You may not be able to match every offer, and I wrote about competing when you cannot win on pay in You Are Not Going To Win On Pay, but you can make sure fairness is never the reason they leave.
Keeping your best people is a theme throughout my culture keynote, You Are Capable of a Better Culture, and my team keynote, Your Team Is Capable of More. See also The MVP Is Not Always The Biggest Number.
Top performers have the most options and often get the least attention. Invest in their growth, recognize their work specifically, protect them from carrying everyone else and from burnout, pay them fairly and ask often what they want next.
Frequently asked questions
How do you keep top performers?
Why do high performers quit?
How do you recognize a top performer?
How do you prevent top performers from burning out?
You Are Capable of More
A No-Excuses Guide to Becoming Your Best Self. The bestselling book behind Chris’s keynotes and the 2026 Paris Book Festival winner in the How-To category. Many teams hand a copy to every seller at their kickoff.
Bring this to
your team.
Chris Sund speaks on this in You Are Capable of a Better Culture and Your Team Is Capable of More, for conferences, leadership teams and company meetings.
All Hiring and Retention Articles · In Inc.: Stop Building Fences to Keep Your Employees · In Forbes: Employee Expectations and Attracting Top Talent
Keynote, breakout or virtual · Response within one business day
More About ChrisInc. ArticlesForbes CouncilBook Chris to Speak