Email vs. In-Person Sales: The 34x Difference
Research found face-to-face requests were 34 times more effective than email. How salespeople can use the Scale of Connectedness to choose the right channel at every stage of a deal.
In a study by Mahdi Roghanizad and Vanessa Bohns, face-to-face requests were 34 times more effective than emailed ones, even though emailers expected to do just as well. Use the Scale of Connectedness to choose channels: email for details and confirmations, and calls, video or in-person meetings for discovery, objections, bad news and the big ask.
Every salesperson makes the same small decision dozens of times a day: do I send this, call, get on video or go see them? Most of the time we pick without thinking, and most of the time we pick whatever is fastest. That habit can cost more deals than we realize.
The good news is that the right channel is not hard to choose once you have a simple way to think about it, and the research gives us a clear reason to care.
The 34x finding
Mahdi Roghanizad and Vanessa Bohns ran a study, published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, in which 45 participants each asked 10 strangers to complete a short survey. Half made the request by email and half made it face to face, with the exact same script. The in-person requests were 34 times more effective. The people sending emails expected to do about as well as the people asking in person, and they were wrong by a wide margin.
The researchers’ explanation is one every salesperson should hear. When you send an email, you know you are trustworthy and your request is legitimate. The person receiving it does not. To them, a message from someone they do not know can look like one more thing to ignore, or worse, something suspicious to avoid clicking.
The Scale of Connectedness
The Scale of Connectedness gives a simple picture of why this happens. It scores each way we communicate by how much human connection it carries. It is not a scientific scale, but it lines up well with the research and with what most of us have felt on the receiving end.
How much connection each channel carries
- In person: 10. Eye contact, tone, a handshake and the full picture of who you are.
- Live video: 8. You can see each other and react in real time.
- Phone call: 6. Your voice carries warmth and lets you hear hesitation.
- Recorded video: 4. Personal and visual, but one way.
- Email: 2. Useful for details, easy to ignore.
- Text message: 1. Fast and convenient, with almost no room for connection.
The lower a channel sits on the scale, the less of you comes through. Your tone, your warmth, your sincerity and your ability to read the other person all drop away as you move from a conversation to a typed message. That does not make email bad. It makes it the wrong tool for the moments that matter most.
The more important the conversation, the higher up the scale it belongs.
Which channel to use, stage by stage
Matching the channel to the moment
- First outreach: a short, personal email or LinkedIn message can open the door, but aim to move to a call or video as quickly as you can.
- Discovery: live video or in person, so you can see reactions and ask good follow-up questions.
- The big ask: as high on the scale as possible. Proposals can travel by email, but the conversation about them should not.
- Objections: phone or better. An objection over email turns into a debate. In a conversation you can listen, acknowledge and ask, the way my LAARC method teaches.
- Bad news: never by text or email first. Call, then follow up in writing.
- Confirmations and recaps: email is perfect here, and it gives everyone a clear record.
- Thank-yous: a handwritten note sits off the scale in its own way, because almost nobody sends one anymore.
People are more willing than you think
Earlier research by Frank Flynn and Vanessa Bohns found that people underestimated by as much as 50% how likely others were to agree to a direct request for help. Salespeople do this constantly. We assume the buyer is too busy, the timing is wrong or the answer will be no, so we soften the ask, bury it in an email or never make it at all.
I would rather make the ask clearly and personally and hear a real answer. A no in a conversation usually comes with a reason you can work with. Silence after an email comes with nothing.
A fair caution
The 34x study involved strangers and small requests, not buyers deciding on a large purchase, so I would not promise anyone a 34 times better close rate. What the research does show, very clearly, is that the channel changes the answer and that we consistently overestimate how persuasive we are in writing. That is reason enough to pick up the phone more often.
For the relationship side of this, read How to Build Client Relationships in Today’s Market and How to Build Instant Rapport. For the writing you still need to do, see How to Write a Sales Email and How to Get a Meeting With a Buyer Who Will Not Call You Back. If your team needs this, it is part of You Are Capable of More Sales. Learn more about my work as a sales keynote speaker.
Research sources: Western University on Roghanizad and Bohns · Flynn and Bohns, If You Need Help, Just Ask
Email is great for details and terrible for trust. In one study, in-person requests were 34 times more effective than email. Match the channel to the moment, move important conversations up the Scale of Connectedness and make the ask personally.
Frequently asked questions
Is in-person selling better than email?
When should salespeople use email?
What is the Scale of Connectedness?
Does the 34x study apply to closing deals?
You Are Capable of More
A No-Excuses Guide to Becoming Your Best Self. The bestselling book behind Chris’s keynotes and the winner of five book awards: the Literary Titan Gold Book Award, Paris Book Festival, Firebird, BookFest and PenCraft Book Awards.
Make the ask
in person.
Chris Sund brings this to sales teams in You Are Capable of More Sales, built on his LOCKS framework and LAARC method, for sales kickoffs, conferences and sales meetings.
Keynote, breakout or virtual · Response within one business day