How to Recruit for Hard-to-Fill Shifts
Nights, weekends and holidays are hard to fill with job ads alone. What works is showing candidates what those shifts are really like, from the people who choose to work them.
To recruit for hard-to-fill shifts such as nights and weekends, share real stories from employees who work those shifts and why they stay, be specific about schedule, pay differentials and flexibility, target candidates whose lives fit those hours, build a strong team culture on those shifts, offer predictable scheduling and make sure night and weekend staff get the same recognition and leadership attention as day shift.
I was consulting with a client that was struggling to get applicants for night shift roles. They were posting jobs constantly, highlighting great benefits and competitive pay, and getting almost nothing. Then they posted one story: a nurse who had reached a milestone anniversary, talking about why she had stayed so long, how her manager worked with her schedule so she could be there for her kids and how the team had her back on the hardest nights and became people she was close to outside of work.
That one post outperformed every job post they had put out. Same job. Same hospital. Different story. I wrote about it in Same Job. Same Hospital. Different Story.
Tell the real story
Candidates considering nights or weekends want to know what those shifts actually feel like. Who will they work with? Will they be supported? Will leadership know their name? Stories from people who work those shifts, and choose to stay, answer those questions far better than a list of benefits. See How to Use Employee Stories to Recruit.
Be specific about what makes it work
Be clear about the practical details that matter: the exact schedule, shift differentials, how often hours change, how time off works and how much flexibility there is. For many people, a predictable night schedule that lets them be home for school pickup is exactly what they are looking for.
Seven ways to fill hard shifts
- Share real stories. From people who choose those shifts.
- Be specific. Schedule, differentials and flexibility.
- Target the right people. Students, parents and night owls.
- Build shift culture. A team people want to join.
- Keep schedules predictable. Stability is a benefit.
- Recognize night and weekend staff. Equally.
- Ask current staff to refer. They know who would fit.
Target people whose lives fit those hours
Some people prefer nights and weekends: students, parents who want days with their kids, people with second jobs or caregiving responsibilities and natural night owls. Write your messages and choose your channels with them in mind.
Build a culture on those shifts
Night and weekend teams often feel forgotten. Leaders who show up occasionally on those shifts, recognize those teams and include them in decisions build loyalty that shows up in referrals and retention. When the shift itself has a strong culture, recruiting becomes much easier.
Ask your current staff
The people already working those shifts know who else might thrive on them. Ask for referrals, and make it easy. See How to Build an Employee Referral Program.
Recruiting and retention are part of You Are Capable of a Better Culture. See also How to Write Job Postings That Attract the Right Candidates and How to Recruit Nurses to a Rural Hospital.
Hard-to-fill shifts are filled with stories, not just ads. Share real stories from people who choose those shifts, be specific about schedules and differentials, target people whose lives fit those hours, build a culture on those shifts and ask current staff to refer.
Frequently asked questions
How do you fill night shift positions?
Why are night shifts hard to fill?
Who prefers to work night shifts?
What works better than job ads for hard-to-fill shifts?
You Are Capable of More
A No-Excuses Guide to Becoming Your Best Self. The bestselling book behind Chris’s keynotes and the 2026 Paris Book Festival winner in the How-To category. Many teams hand a copy to every seller at their kickoff.
Bring this to
your team.
Chris Sund speaks on this in You Are Capable of a Better Culture, for conferences, leadership teams and company meetings.
All Hiring and Retention Articles · In Forbes: Employee Expectations and Attracting Top Talent
Keynote, breakout or virtual · Response within one business day
More About ChrisInc. ArticlesForbes CouncilBook Chris to Speak